I'll be brief to start, I'm happy to expand on the problem.

I have created a Login, Register page ect. The register page creates a member with a member group regUsr.

I have created the group ext in umbraco.

I have then selected a trial page to protect using "public access" so only regUsr users can view it.

No matter what I try the login always works, it says you're logged in but will always default to the page that I created for the error page "Used when people are logged on, but do not have access" am I missing something simple.

Thanks